Last Updated on April 9, 2025 by JJ
Tucked away in Sarasota, Florida, lies Pinecraft, a unique and fascinating Amish and Mennonite community. Unlike the traditional farmlands of Pennsylvania or Ohio, this vibrant neighborhood offers a sunny, coastal lifestyle where Amish families come to vacation, retire, or live year-round. Here, horse-drawn buggies give way to bicycles and three-wheeled adult trikes, yet the values of simplicity, faith, and craftsmanship remain deeply rooted. This guide explores Pinecraft’s history, culture, must-visit spots, and local dining, providing an authentic glimpse into Florida’s Amish way of life.
1. The History & Origins of Pinecraft
???? Sarasota, FL
While most Amish communities are located in the Midwest and Northeast, Pinecraft emerged as a winter retreat in the 1920s. Early Amish and Mennonite settlers were drawn to Sarasota’s warm climate and the chance to escape harsh northern winters. Over time, what began as a seasonal escape became a permanent settlement for some families, with Amish and Mennonite visitors arriving by bus instead of horse and buggy.
Unlike rural Amish farms, Pinecraft’s homes are modest, colorful cottages with electricity—though televisions and computers remain absent. While traditional black bonnets and plain dresses are still worn, you’ll also find Amish men in suspenders and straw hats, pedaling tricycles down the palm-lined streets.
???? More about Amish history in Sarasota
Where to Stay Nearby:
- Carlisle Inn Sarasota – A charming hotel owned by a Mennonite family, offering a peaceful retreat with homemade breakfasts. Website
- Hibiscus Suites Inn – A cozy, family-friendly stay near Siesta Key Beach. Website
2. Amish Businesses & Handmade Crafts
???? Main Street, Pinecraft
Pinecraft is known for its exceptional Amish craftsmanship, from handmade quilts and furniture to fresh produce. Unlike traditional Amish communities that focus on farming, Pinecraft’s residents run small businesses, bakeries, and local markets.
Best Places for Amish Goods:
- Yoder’s Amish Village – Famous for handmade quilts, home-cooked meals, and homemade pies. Website
- Amish Gift & Quilt Shop – A treasure trove of intricate quilts, wooden crafts, and handmade goods. Website
???? Learn more about Amish craftsmanship
3. Florida’s Amish Food Scene – Best Restaurants
???? Pinecraft & Sarasota
Amish cooking is rich, hearty, and deeply comforting, featuring freshly baked bread, slow-roasted meats, and homemade desserts. Pinecraft has some of the best Amish-style restaurants in Florida, offering everything from chicken pot pie to peanut butter pie.
Must-Try Amish Restaurants:
- Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village – A legendary spot for fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and homemade pies. Website
- Der Dutchman Sarasota – Serves all-you-can-eat Amish buffet favorites like roast beef, stuffing, and fresh pies. Website
- Big Olaf Creamery – An Amish-owned ice cream shop, famous for hand-churned flavors. Website
???? Find more Amish restaurants in Florida
4. Exploring Pinecraft Park & Outdoor Life
???? Pinecraft Park, Sarasota
While the Amish are known for their hard work and discipline, leisure and recreation also play a role in their community bonding. Pinecraft Park is a popular gathering place where Amish families enjoy shuffleboard, volleyball, and storytelling.
???? Biking culture is huge in Pinecraft—without horse-drawn buggies, most Amish rely on three-wheeled adult tricycles to get around. Visitors can rent one and take a leisurely ride through Pinecraft’s quaint streets.
???? More about Pinecraft Park
Where to Stay Nearby:
- Aloft Sarasota – A modern hotel close to Amish businesses and Siesta Key Beach. Website
5. Amish Church & Community Gatherings
???? Pinecraft Mennonite Church
Faith remains the center of Amish life, and while horse-drawn church services don’t exist in Pinecraft, traditional worship and prayer gatherings continue.
The Pinecraft Mennonite Church welcomes visitors to attend Sunday services, where Amish hymns are sung in German and English.
???? More on Amish faith in Florida
6. The Amish Bus Migration – Unique Travel Tradition
???? Sarasota Station – Pioneer Trails
One of the most fascinating aspects of Amish travel is the bus migration. Since the Amish don’t drive cars, Pioneer Trails Bus Lines runs a dedicated Amish-only bus service between Florida and Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana.
During the winter months, hundreds of Amish families arrive in Sarasota by bus, creating a seasonal influx of visitors that transforms Pinecraft into a bustling winter village.
???? Pioneer Trails Bus Schedule
7. Pinecraft’s Amish Markets – A Culinary Experience
???? Pinecraft & Sarasota Farmers’ Market
Pinecraft’s markets are a must-visit, filled with freshly baked bread, farm-grown vegetables, and homemade cheese.
Best Amish Markets in Sarasota:
- Pinecraft Farmers’ Market – The best place to buy fresh produce, dairy, and homemade jams.
- Sarasota Farmers Market – Features Amish vendors selling homemade cheese, honey, and baked goods. Website
Plan Your Amish-Inspired Florida Visit
Pinecraft offers a rare glimpse into Amish life in a tropical setting, blending tradition with modernity. Whether you’re indulging in homemade pies, exploring quilt shops, or riding a three-wheeled bike, a trip to this unique Amish retreat is an unforgettable experience.
???? More Amish Culture in Florida:
???? Book a Pinecraft Bike Tour:
- Three-Wheel Bike Rentals: Website
